The good news is this stuff above has zero fat in it. Unless there is a trace of fat in the tomatoes. Just remember that tomatoes are actually a fruit. We tend to forget that. And actually, this saucy stuff took a bit of sugar, even though tomatoes are in their sweet prime here these days.
When I read the write-up and recipe over at Kate in the Kitchen, I was intrigued. I went off and did something else for several hours, and then got to thinking about Tomato Jam. It just sounded so interesting. I remembered it was from Kate’s blog (fortunately) so I quickly re-found it and saved it to my recipe software. Kate got the recipe from the cookbook: Herbivoracious: A Flavor Revolution with 150 Vibrant and Original Vegetarian Recipes. You can find the recipe at the Herbivoracious website.
In the ensuing couple of weeks I’ve thought about it several times. I take that as a sign that I’m supposed to fix something if I can’t get it out of my mind! Then when my DH happened to mention that our corner farm stand was offering 10+ pounds of tomatoes for $10, I said sure, do it. So obviously, I had a few tomatoes to use up. After two rounds of caprese salad, I gave a couple of tomatoes away, then STILL had about 8 tomatoes. Tomato jam, coming up!
The jam is cinchy easy to make. Truly. I tweaked the recipe just a little – both from the original and Kate’s too, but not by much. I used less salt, less sugar, and maybe a tetch more rosemary. I love rosemary (Kate doesn’t, so she used lemon thyme, oregano and parsley, I think she said, instead of the rosemary). As you can see, the recipe can be altered to suit you or your family. You and your taste buds.
The tomatoes are peeled raw (top photo) – providing you have the Messermeister Pro Touch Swivel Peeler (otherwise you need to dunk them in boiling water for a minute and peel them hot) and chopped, then combined in a good, sturdy pot with all the other ingredients (lower photo) to simmer gently for an hour or more. It oozes out a lot of juice, but by simmering it long and slow, eventually all the watery juice boils off, leaving you with a jam consistency.
The recipe below makes about 1 cup. But you may want to make more. It surely could be canned too (in a water bath), then you could put it on your pantry shelf for up to a year. You could freeze it in small containers and it would keep for at least a year also. Or, make it in a small batch and use it up within a week. I’d really be surprised that it wouldn’t keep longer than that – it’s got a lot of sugar in it – it’s like fruit jam, so why wouldn’t it keep? If anybody knows more about that I’d welcome comments. I have a condiment in the refrigerator that I made 6 months ago (the sauce from the Ribeye Steaks with Amazing Glaze). It’s still just fine – no mold or off flavors.
What I didn’t know was what I was going to DO with the stuff. So okay, I have about a cup of tomato jam. Now what? I went on the trusty internet – amazing what you can find if you look – I discovered it’s great over cream cheese. (It was fantastic that way – loved it!) It makes a great condiment on meat sandwiches. It can be used instead of ketchup. And it can be served on toast in the morning too. I’m thinking it would be great on a piece of grilled fish. Or grilled chicken. There are plenty of recipes for tomato jam out there – all different. Every one of them has a little different use for it.
What I liked: the flavors, of course. I just love complex flavors and there are ample (from the tomatoes themselves, the rosemary, the lemon zest although you really can’t pick that out, and the lemon juice). This jam is very versatile.
What I didn’t like: well, if I’d made a big batch, apparently it would take awhile to cook it down (maybe more than 2 hours) but doing just this batch was fine. Love the stuff. Nothing I didn’t like!
MasterCook 5+ import file – right click to save file, run MC, then File|Import
Tomato Jam
Recipe By: Adapted slightly from Kate in the Kitchen blog 7/2012 (she got it from Herbivoracious, a cookbook).
Serving Size: 10
Serving Ideas: Use as a topping on cream cheese. Or with some kind of stinky cheese (Camembert, for instance), even Brie. With crackers. Can be used in lieu of ketchup in a sandwich (roast beef, tomato slices, lettuce or a ham sandwich, oh yes!). And truly, you COULD put it on toast in the morning. You’d be hard pressed to know it’s not a berry jam if you weren’t able to see the tomato-y color. I think it would be great with fish or chicken. Even as a condiment on a big, honkin’ ribeye steak. Beef and tomatoes are a match made in heaven anyway!
NOTES: The sugar has been reduced – depending upon how sweet the tomatoes are, you may want to adjust the sugar further. The original called for 3/4 cup – that’s definitely too much!
1 1/2 pounds fresh tomatoes — peeled, chopped
1/2 small red onion — diced finely
1/2 cup sugar — or less
1 teaspoon lemon zest
2 tablespoons lemon juice
1 teaspoon kosher salt
2 tablespoons chopped fresh rosemary
1 pinch saffron threads
1 pinch crushed red pepper
Fresh ground black pepper
1. Peel tomatoes and chop coarsely.
2. In a medium saucepan, combine all the ingredients except the black pepper. Bring to a boil, reduce the heat and allow to simmer until the jam has thickened, about an hour or more. Stir every few minutes while it simmers. Add pepper.
3. Allow to cool (it thickens up as it cools) then store in refrigerator. Use within a week or freeze it. Or can it. Yield: 1 cup
Per Serving: 56 Calories; trace Fat (3.5% calories from fat); 1g Protein; 14g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 0mg Cholesterol; 194mg Sodium.

Lana @ Never Enough Thyme
said on August 17th, 2012:
I enjoy making tomato jam, too. Here’s one more way to use it if you’re interested: http://www.lanascooking.com/2011/03/10/savory-french-toast/
What a great idea, Lana! I like the idea of the savory addition to French toast. I rarely make it, but this might inspire me. I’m also a fan of Laura Calder’s program. In fact I have one show on my Tivo that I’ve marked as permanent save because I keep going back to it (it was one she did about preserving and canning). Thanks much for the idea. . . carolyn t
hddonna
said on August 18th, 2012:
My grandmother always made tomato preserves–similar to this recipe except that they contained slices of lemon, but not the onion and spices. This looks really interesting–I’m going to have to try it! It sounds marvelous as a sandwich condiment. Grandma canned her preserves, and I did that once or twice, years ago. These days, I freeze it in small quantities, and I find it keeps just fine for a couple of years. It’s not going to spoil in the freezer, so it will certainly be safe; the flavor hasn’t suffered with the preserves, but since this version contains the onions and spices, the flavors might not be as stable. Still, I think it would probably be fine for longer than the suggested six months–definitely worth a try.
I’m sure you’ve noted that canning, preserving, jam-making, etc. are all making a big comeback. I used to make jams years and years ago when I had good (and inexpensive) sources of fruit. Haven’t done it for years, though. I just made a 3-pound batch of the tomato jam yesterday and will probably put the multiple little jars in the freezer!. . . carolyn t
Toffeeapple
said on August 20th, 2012:
This sounds lovely Carolyn. Over here we don’t tend to water-bath things unless they contain meat, on the premise that sugar is a very good preservative.