Lime Jell-o Salad with Pineapple

In a way it’s sad that Jell-O salads aren’t a regular on our tables anymore. This one is SO good.

Laugh with me here: I grew up in the era of Jell-O salads, I’ve always loved them. And let me tell you, when you serve them now, they’re usually gone in a flash. They have a bad rap – because of all the sugar in the mix. I have made them with the sugar-free version. Can’t say that they taste the same, and they have fewer flavors of sugar-free.

Recently two friends and I put on a luncheon that was a trip into our past, to the 50s and 60s. I’ve already posted the appetizer, the olive-stuffed cheese balls, and I will also post the wild rice casserole I made too. My friend Linda (I have two Linda friends who cook, one local and one about 50 miles away), the one who lives locally, made her version of this salad, combined a little with mine. My version uses cream cheese instead of cottage cheese. I like them both. Both had canned, drained crushed pineapple. Mine used to have mini-marshmallows on top, though I don’t make it that way anymore. Too sweet. Both recipes contained chopped pecans. My recipe used 7UP for the liquid – part water to dissolve the mix, then 7UP for the remainder of the liquid. You can use diet jell-o and diet 7up if you’d like to.

When Linda and I were starting to serve, I thought about making it just like we did back in the day, with a lettuce leaf underneath (that would get soggy and rarely was eaten) and with a tiny dollop of mayo on top with a maraschino cherry. We all chuckled about that last, the maraschino cherry.

What’s GOOD: love this salad. Tangy from the 7UP (just a little) and the creamy texture from the cottage cheese. Flavorful from the drained pineapple too. And can’t forget the pecans that add texture. Linda told me this is her husband Larry’s very favorite salad, bar none. He always asks for it during the holidays.

What’s NOT: just that you may want to make this the day ahead as it needs several hours of chilling time.

printer-friendly PDF and MasterCook file (click link to open recipe)

* Exported from MasterCook *

Lime Jell-o Salad with Pineapple

Recipe: An ancient recipe from the 1960s
Servings: 8

3 ounces Jell-O Gelatin Dessert, Lime
8 ounces crushed pineapple — drained
3 ounces cottage cheese — or cream cheese
1 cup boiling water
1 cup 7UP — chilled, if possible
1 cup marshmallows — tiny ones (optional) [we didn’t use them]
1/2 cup chopped pecans
Garnish: a tiny dollop of mayo and a maraschino cherry

1. Add boiling water to Jell-o to dissolve. Allow mixture to cool some before continuing. Stir in the cottage cheese. If using cream cheese, use a whisk to distribute it evenly.
2. Add 7-up, pecans and marshmallows (if using). Allow to cool to room temp, then pour into a mold (round ring mold or a ceramic square-ish dish) and refrigerate until set, 3-6 hours, or overnight.
3. Cut into servings and dollop with mayo and a maraschino cherry.
Per Serving: 205 Calories; 5g Fat (21.7% calories from fat); 3g Protein; 39g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 1mg Cholesterol; 106mg Sodium; 31g Total Sugars; 0mcg Vitamin D; 23mg Calcium; trace Iron; 78mg Potassium; 39mg Phosphorus.