Olive-Filled Cheese Balls

Nostalgia here. I used to make these over and over again, back in the 60s and 70s. Do you remember them too?

A few weeks ago two friends of mine and I hosted a luncheon for a group of 10 of us ladies, a fundraiser that the guests all paid money to attend. We decided to do a dip into the past, the 50s and 60s. You’re going to see a few recipes from this event in coming weeks. This appetizer, a salad, and an entree too. Lois made some meatballs (I forgot to take a picture or I’d post that recipe too) cooked in chili sauce and grape jelly (remember those variations?). Linda made the lime Jell-O salad which I just loved, almost identical to the one I used to make. We also made my mother’s crisp apple pudding with whipped cream, which harkens back to the 1930s I would guess, but I grew up with having it in the 50s.

These little cocktail appetizers are not hard to make, though you do have to mix up the dough, flatten a teaspoon or so of it to enclose a pimiento-stuffed olive, chill them in the frig for an hour or so, then bake them. When I made them years ago I’d double the recipe and once baked I’d freeze them on a cookie sheet, then pile them into a freezer container, all ready for some dinner party when I’d pull them out and re-bake them.

The recipe I had differed a little from Lois’s recipe here, but they tasted much the same, so I’m using hers except for the addition of paprika to the dough. At the time (the 60s), these were quite the “thing,” and because some people didn’t like fussing with a dough, they were very special. Truly, they’re not difficult to make, and you’ll hear raves from your guests. They can be served hot or at room temp.

What’s GOOD: the contrast of the cheese dough and the astringency of the stuffed olive are a good balance. Cheesy, briny all in one. These are a winner and here we are 60+ years later, making them again, and they’re still just as good as in the 1960s. Great to freeze and have on hand.

What’s NOT: only that you do have to “fuss” a bit with the dough, flattening it out to encircle the olive. You don’t want olive juice in there either or the dough won’t seal well.

printer-friendly PDF and MasterCook file (click link to open recipe)

* Exported from MasterCook *

Olive-Filled Cheese Balls

Recipe: An old 1960s recipe from my friend Lois
Servings: 20 (two per person)

2 cups sharp cheddar cheese — grated
1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1/8 teaspoon paprika
1/2 cup butter — melted
40 green olives — stuffed with pimiento, jarred, drained

1. Mix cheese, paprika and flour together. Add melted butter and mix thoroughly. If dough seems dry, mix with your hands – the warmth of your hands will help bring the dough together.
2. Meanwhile, place olives on a few paper towels to drain and kind of dry. You don’t want a wet olive or the dough won’t seal correctly.
3. Mold a teaspoon of dough around an olive, shaping it into a ball. Place about 2″ apart on an ungreased baking sheet. Cover and chill for about an hour.
4. Preheat oven to 400°F. Bake olives for about 15-16 minutes. They do not need to get brown around the edges. Allow to cool a few minutes before serving. Or cool to room temperature and serve. You can freeze the balls, once they’ve been baked and cooled, and reheat from a frozen state for 15 minutes at 400°F.
Per Serving: 174 Calories; 13g Fat (69.5% calories from fat); 7g Protein; 7g Carbohydrate; trace Dietary Fiber; 36mg Cholesterol; 273mg Sodium; trace Total Sugars; trace Vitamin D; 174mg Calcium; trace Iron; 30mg Potassium; 119mg Phosphorus.