Peach Cobbler–specifically, Dottie’s Peach Cobbler
When we were in Denver, I was telling my friend Sue about the great new recipe I’d found for Peach Crisp. You read my blog post about it last month – it was an America’s Test Kitchen recipe. And I was explaining how I just have to have a crispy crust on my peach desserts – nothing else will do. Since you may have forgotten – just like I had – what the differences are between crisps and cobblers, crumbles and grunts, here’s a little primer, taken from my little bitty cookbook called Cobblers, Crumbles & Crisps and Other Old-Fashioned Fruit Desserts:
Cobblers: similar to a deep-dish pie and topped with a sweet pastry of biscuit-type crust.
Pandowdy: similar to a deep-dish pie, but was usually served for breakfast and made of apples. The “dowdying” part comes from the custom of pushing the crust down through the fruit part way through and baking some more
Slumps & Grunts: A stove-top cobbler starting with stewed fruit and feather-light dumplings that absorb some of the fruit’s juices.
Crumbles & Crisps: usually interchangeable, composed of lightly sweetened fruit topped with an easy crumbly shortbread pastry. In Great Britain crisps are called crumbles and the toppings usually contain rolled oats.
Bettys: a cousin to Crisps and Crumbles. Usually, today, the fruit is layered with bread crumbs.
Buckles: similar to a breakfast cake, usually made with berries, and folded or strewn over the batter before baking.
So there’s your cooking vernacular lesson for today. A couple of years ago I also posted a biscuit-topped peach cobbler that was really good too. And last summer I made Pioneer Woman’s version of peach crisp with maple whipped cream. As I recall it was really soupy with juice. Loved the topping, but wasn’t all that crazy about the peaches part.
Anyway, Sue told me about her family’s favorite peach cobbler and about the crispy crust it has. Yes, indeed. One of her mother’s best friends, Dottie, gave her the recipe, and it’s what Sue and her family think of as the only peach crisp there is out there! Sue made it our last night there. It was a warm night, just the kind when you want to have a soothing fruit dessert with some icy-cold ice cream to go along with it. I enjoyed it a lot! And absolutely it did have a very crispy top. Another recipe for my peach archive! Thanks again, Sue.
What I liked: the crispiest crust I may have ever had on a peach dessert of this type. It’s almost cookie-like, thin and crispy. You can vary the amount of butter added into it (between 4-8 T.) and do note that you can scant the sugar in the topping by a little bit too. We left the next day, so didn’t have a chance to taste it then to see how the crust fared after being refrigerated. Maybe Sue will comment below and tell us.
What I didn’t like: nothing at all. It’s a keeper!
printer-friendly PDF
MasterCook 5+ import file
Peach Cobbler – Dottie’s Peach Cobbler
Recipe By: From my friend Sue, and it’s from her mother’s friend Dottie.
Serving Size: 8
NOTES: If you’d like to use apples, substitute 1/3 cup (rather than 2/3 cup in peach mixture) of BROWN sugar. You can also use less butter – with little noticeable difference – as little as 4 T. rather than the full cube.
PEACH MIXTURE:
1/2 cup butter — melted (or less)
2 cups peaches — or apples, sliced
2/3 cup sugar — if using apples, reduce to 1/3 cup brown sugar
COBBLER TOPPING:
1 cup sugar — scant
3/4 cup flour
1 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons baking powder
3/4 cup milk
1 teaspoon vanilla
1. Combine peaches with melted butter and sugar. Pour into bottom of a 9×9 glass baking dish.
2. Combine topping mixture and stir just until combined. Pour over peaches and bake at 350° for 60 minutes, until mixture is golden brown.
3. Cool slightly and serve with vanilla ice cream or whipped cream.
Per Serving: 340 Calories; 12g Fat (32.1% calories from fat); 2g Protein; 57g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 34mg Cholesterol; 517mg Sodium.
A year ago: Marinated Tomatoes
Four years ago: Brunch Gratinee Eggs