Grilled Portobello Mushrooms with Arugula Butter and Parmigiano

That photo doesn’t tell you a whole lot about how good this was. Brown food is kind of hard to photograph, period. And brown food doesn’t always look that appetizing. That’s a Portobello mushroom with the stem and gills scraped out, filled with arugula butter then topped with ample grated Parmesan cheese.  And grilled.

It’s really very easy. You do have to make the arugula butter in the food processor (arugula chopped up, fresh garlic, butter and a bit of fresh lemon juice plus salt and pepper). It takes a minute or so to pry out the stem of the mushroom and use a spoon to scrape out the gills. Then the arugula butter is kind of slathered in the mushroom. Then freshly grated Parmesan was sprinkled on top. And it’s grilled for 20 minutes. Done.

My DH fired up the grill to high, heated up my dandy new Williams-Sonoma grilling basket for five minutes over direct heat until it was hotter than a pistol, then he removed it to the side. He used an oil-dampened paper towel to rub over the basket bottom, then I gently placed the mushrooms inside. Back on the grill they went.

The recipe came from my new favorite barbecue cookbook, Steven Raichlen’s grilling cookbook The Barbecue! Bible. I adapted it very slightly – oiled the bottom of the mushroom, more garlic and more cheese. That was our dinner entree, actually. We enjoyed it with some freshly grilled corn and an heirloom tomato salad with fresh Mozzie and an arugula salad tumbled on top of it.

printer-friendly PDF

Grilled Portobello Mushrooms with Arugula Butter

Recipe By: Adapted from The Barbecue! Bible by Steven Raichlen
Serving Size: 4
Notes: Since you already have a bag or bunch of arugula, do make a vinaigrette-dressed arugula salad with the remainder of the arugula. Depending on the size of the mushrooms, this can be an entree or a side dish.

1/2 bunch arugula leaves — chopped
1 small clove garlic — chopped
4 tablespoons unsalted butter
Salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste
A few drops of lemon juice
4 large Portobello mushroom caps
3 tablespoons Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese — grated

1. Preheat grill to high.
2. Combine in a food processor the arugula and garlic. Puree, then add the butter, salt, pepper and lemon juice. Taste it and correct the seasoning if needed.
3. Prepare the mushroom caps – remove the stems (gently twist or push to the side and remove), then use a teaspoon to scrape out the gills and discard. Rub the mounded mushroom cap with a little bit of olive oil, if desired.
4. Spread the arugula butter inside the mushroom caps all the way out to the edges. Sprinkle top with Parmigiano cheese.
5. Preheat a grill basket for 5 minutes. Remove (carefully, it’s hot), rub the basket with an oil-soaked paper towel, then carefully place the mushroom caps in the basket.
6. Bank the coals on one side, or turn off one of the burners so the mushrooms will cook with indirect heat. Grill for 20 minutes (still on high heat) , approximately. Thinner mushrooms may be done in 15 minutes, but a regular, thick Portobello will take the full 20 minutes. Very carefully remove from the grill so the butter doesn’t escape and serve. Allow to cool for 3-4 minutes before eating as the butter is very, very hot.
Per Serving: 151 Calories; 13g Fat (73.8% calories from fat); 4g Protein; 6g Carbohydrate; 2g Dietary Fiber; 34mg Cholesterol; 77mg Sodium.

A year ago: Photo from our Alaska cruise, the Inland Passage
Two years ago: Sweet and Sour Eggplant