Arborio Rice Pudding – both vanilla and chocolate
Thank goodness for the internet. Otherwise I’d have made Dorie Greenspan’s rice pudding recipe straight out of the cookbook and not known it contained two typo’s. And I’d have been very disappointed to have made a sweet rice and milk soup rather than a more solid rice pudding. Years ago there was no way to ever know about typographical errors in cookbooks.
My friend Norma was ready for another dessert, and after going through some ideas she decided rice pudding sounded the best. I have several recipes for it, but knew Dorie Greenspan’s ought to be the best out there. How chagrined she must be to have such major typo’s appear in her wonderful cookbook. Whatever happened to proofreaders at publishing houses? I’ve made a couple of errors on my recipes here on this blog, but I don’t have a proofreader (except for moi), so you get what you get when you read it here! This recipe is from her book: Baking: From My Home to Yours.
Anyway, this recipe is different than some. My mother used to make rice pudding. I’m sure yours did too. I don’t know what recipe my mom used, since I didn’t find one in her recipe box. But because Dorie used Arborio rice (the type used to make Italian risotto), I was intrigued with it. Then in reading her recipe I discovered that you parboil the rice in water first. Parboil means to cook briefly, partially – it’s a culinary technique that can be used for other things – like vegetables. To parboil means to partially cook something, for continuing to cook it later. It’s just a method of submerging the item in boiling water and cooking it for a minute or two. In this case the rice is cooked for ten minutes (the parboil part). So here, you simmer the rice in water first. Then it’s drained and rinsed (the rinsing of cooked rice was something I’d never done) before combining with the milk and sugar and simmering it for nearly an hour. 45 minutes to be exact. Then you add vanilla, or the chocolate, or divide the batch in half and do both, as I did.
This rice pudding is not a firm pudding – it has no eggs or cornstarch to thicken it – just milk and rice. That’s it. Even after chilling overnight, the pudding is not firm. I liked it this way. It’s also not overly sweet, either. I liked that part of it too. Most of the others who have made Dorie’s rice pudding agreed that both the chocolate and the vanilla types were good. Neither one was better than the other. Combining them – as I did for the photo above – looked pretty – but I’m not sure I’d actually serve it that way because the chocolate version overpowered the vanilla. But this way you could easily make 2 chocolate puds and 2 vanilla puds. Or 3 and 1. Whatever. I used more rice, and I added some half and half instead of milk for part of it (I made a triple quantity), and I cooked the milk-rice mixture for about 45 minutes before cooling it; all of these alterations are included in the recipe below.
printer-friendly PDF
Arborio Rice Pudding
Recipe: Corrected recipe from Dorie Greenspan,
Baking: From My Home to Yours
Servings: 4
Serving Ideas: I don’t really recommend combining the two types in a single serving – the chocolate flavor overpowers the vanilla. Do one or the other. Both are good.
1/2 cup arborio rice
2 cups water
3 1/4 cups whole milk — (I used some half and half)
1/4 cup sugar
1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract — (for the vanilla/white pudding)
1 1/2 ounces bittersweet chocolate (for the black/chocolate type)
1. Pour the rice and water in a heavy-bottomed saucepan and bring to a boil. Lower the temperature and cook the rice, uncovered, for 10 minutes. Drain the rice in a strainer and rinse it; set aside.
2. Rinse out the saucepan, then pour in the whole milk, stir in the sugar, and set the pan over medium heat. When the milk mixture boils, stir in the parboiled rice. Reduce the heat to low and let the mixture bubble away gently, stirring occasionally, for about 50-60 minutes. As the pudding gets close to done, the rice kernels will be visible in the boiling milk- you’ll see them floating under the top layer of milk. The pudding won’t be thick- that’s okay as it will thicken in the refrigerator – but the rice will be soft and it will have absorbed 80 to 90 percent of the milk.
3. Remove the pan from the heat and decide what flavor you’d like the pudding to be – add either the vanilla or chocolate and stir gently until it is fully blended in to the pudding.
4. Pour the pudding into a serving bowl or into individual cups or bowls. Press plastic wrap against the surface of the pudding to prevent it from forming a skin, and refrigerate for at least 6 hours, until thoroughly cold.
Per Serving: 259 Calories; 7g Fat (23.3% calories from fat); 8g Protein; 41g Carbohydrate; 0g Dietary Fiber; 27mg Cholesterol; 105mg Sodium.
A year ago: Eggplant – everything you always wanted to know
Two years ago: Herbed Biscuit Ring (an easy, but delish biscuit made from tube biscuits)