And so, on the quest for softer, chewier CC cookies

When I got married (the ill-fated first time) back in 1962, I received one cookbook amongst the wedding and shower gifts. I don’t remember who gave it to me, but I have it still, the 1962 edition of the Joy of Cooking. I cooked from it for years. And years. I read the lengthy treatises at the beginning of every cooking category, and learned from them. Eventually I bought another cookbook or two. And branched out. Even now, 45 years later, I still go to that cookbook on rare occasions, to locate a basic recipe for something. Meanwhile, my cookbook collection has definitely expanded. If I’d kept all the ones I’ve given away, I’d likely have more than 350 or 400. I think I have about 200 now, maybe a bit less than that. And not a one of them is a Better Homes & Gardens. Read on.

Out of curiosity, I pulled out the poor Joy book (the spine is falling off, so it’s very wobbly and unstable, but I really don’t think I want to replace it) to see what the Rombauer/Becker ladies had to say about chocolate chip cookies. There’s just one recipe, for a chocolate chip drop cookie. It contains only butter, but otherwise the ingredient list is very similar to nearly every other CC cookie recipe out there. There’s a stain on that page, so I assume I may have made it at one time or another, but usually I just made the Nestle bag recipe.

My mother used to make CC cookies as I was growing up, so my love of them goes way back. I think it’s only been in the last couple of years (from reading blogs) that I’ve awakened some hidden interest in finding a better and better version. More chocolaty ones. More crispy. More nutty? Thicker, rather than thinner? Infinite combinations, really.

This particular quest, though, is all about a softer and more chewy variety for my friend Norma. She was nearly out of cookies the other day, and her request is for softer, the softer the better. So after making several other batches that have been too crispy, I dug into my recipe archives to find an article from 1999, printed in the Orange County Register (our local paper here in So. California) called “The great cookie quest.” Written by Tenny Tatusian, it chronicles her 2-month journey to find  a better CC cookie. First she tried a cookie by David Rosengarten, in his book “Taste.” She didn’t like his at all (they contained dark molasses and heavy cream, of all things). All wrong, she thought. Next she tried Nick Malgieri’s recipe. Although good, she thought she could do better somehow. Next came Maida Heatter’s. Good. Buttery. Chocolaty. But too thin, she thought.

Next she tried Shirley Corriher’s recipe. Airy, less sweet, tasty, but too pale. Finally Tatusian decided to try an old workhorse cookbook, Better Homes & Gardens. She struck pay dirt (cookie dough pay dirt, anyway). In taste-testing, this cookie won, hands down. Slightly puffy, dense, and supposedly SOFT. What sets this recipe apart from the mainstream is the mixture of butter and shortening. All-butter CC cookies make a thinner dough and a more crispy cookie. All shortening and I think they’d be too soft and too pale. A mixture of half and half butter/shortening was her E-ticket. And yes, in case you’re interested, I used non-hydrogenated shortening.

Indeed, these cookies are soft. Slightly crispy on the outer edges, but soft inside, even when they’ve cooled down. I had hoped my friend Norma would like these, but her report is that they’re good, but still too crispy. Gosh. Back to the drawing boards, I guess. That’s not to say they aren’t very tasty – I liked them if that says anything. But yes, they did have a bit of crunch to them. Far too much for my friend.
printer-friendly PDF

Soft (well, sort of) Basic Chocolate
Chip Cookies

Recipe: Better Homes & Gardens
Servings: 60

1/2 cup shortening
1/2 cup unsalted butter
1 cup packed brown sugar — golden brown, not dark
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 whole eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1 1/2 cups semisweet chocolate chips
1 cup walnuts — chopped

1. Preheat oven to 375.
2. In a bowl (stand mixer) beat shortening and butter on medium to high speed for 30 seconds. Add both sugars, soda and salt. Beat until combined. Beat in eggs and vanilla.
3. Add flour slowly and mix until combined. Add chocolate chips and nuts and continue mixing just until the chips and nuts are evenly distributed.
4. Line cookie sheets with parchment, or use Silpats. Drop dough by rounded teaspoons two inches apart on cookie sheets. Bake for 10 minutes. Cool cookies on a wire rack.
Per Serving: 103 Calories; 6g Fat (49.4% calories from fat); 1g Protein; 12g Carbohydrate; trace Dietary Fiber; 11mg Cholesterol; 33mg Sodium.

A year ago: Pork Tenderloin with Fig & Port Sauce