Here’s another of those – TRUST ME – recipes. When I tell you these are worth making, please just do it, right? Do you like vivid orange flavors? And chocolate? This positively is a match made in heaven. And they’re super easy too.
Muffin Tips:
(1) don’t over-mix the batter; and (2) bake to 205° internal temp (use a thermometer for that part)
A group of women was coming to my home to attend a cooking class, and each time we meet, the hostess (me this time) provides beverages (hot and cold) and some breakfast sorts of things (croissants maybe, fresh fruit, occasionally champagne) and a bread – perhaps banana bread or muffins. Even cookies. I had nothing particular in mind, but turned to one of my favorite little tiny cookbooks. What I’ve learned over the years is that every recipe in this book, Muffins: Sixty Sweet and Savory Recipes… From Old Favorites to New is reliable. Written by Elizabeth Alston,
it’s out of print, but you can still find it in a used book store. And if you click on the link there, you’ll find some used copies for a penny (plus shipping, of course). I bought it for myself in 2003, when it was new (along with the companion book about Scones – Biscuits and Scones: 62 Recipes from Breakfast Biscuits to Homey Desserts). I also gave these to my daughter Sara, because she and her daughter love to bake. She was telling me a few weeks ago that it’s her go-to cookbook for anything close to a muffin (there are all kinds from savory to sweet, and biscuits too). What’s good about this one is that every single recipe I’ve ever tried (and Sara says the same thing) has been exceptionally good.
Looking online to see what other people thought, I found several versions of this recipe, all with a few little changes. Never did find the exact recipe, so I stuck with Alston’s original, using yogurt as the dairy (you can use buttermilk too).
You might be skeptical at the amount of orange zest in the recipe – 12 muffins require the zest from 2 oranges. My oranges were very large, so I probably had more than usual – about nearly 3 tablespoons that I got using the microplane. And it uses 3 ounces of bittersweet chocolate. I rarely use anything but the best chocolate (SharffenBerger in this case), and the bittersweet is worth seeking out. I did NOT use chocolate chips, and I’m glad I didn’t because they’re too sweet and too uniform – it’s nice to have dots of larger pieces of chocolate. You know you’re eating a really good chocolate that way.
The muffins are standard as far as mixing – cream the butter and sugar, add eggs and beat until light and fluffy. Add the yogurt, orange juice and zest, then the dry ingredients are gently stirred in with the chocolate at the last. There are two secrets to making muffins: (1) don’t over mix the batter – just stir until you don’t see any errant streaks of flour; and (2) bake them to EXACTLY 205°. In my oven that took 18 minutes. I used my fantastic Thermapen thermometer to test them and they were 204.9° exactly. Perfection. I cooled them in the muffin tin for about 10 minutes, then carefully used a plastic knife to release them and let them cool to room temp. And I’m absolutely guilty as heck – I ate one while they were still barely warm. Oh – my – gosh. Was it ever good. Ideally bake them within an hour of serving, when the chocolate is still almost molten, but not quite. As it was, I made them the day before and kept them in a ziploc bag overnight. Reheat them if you’re going to make them ahead – but not for long as they would dry out, I’m sure.
What’s good: oh, the orange flavor and the chocolate. As they say, those are two flavors that are marriage material. Loved the intense orange flavor – much more orange-y than usual in a baked good – but it wasn’t over the top (as in bitter). And the irregular pieces of chocolate were such a sweet surprise as you eat it. Definitely a make-again muffin.
What’s not: absolutely nothing at all.
printer-friendly (Cute PDFWriter) PDF
MasterCook 5+ import file – right click to save file, run MC, then File|Import
* Exported from MasterCook *
Chocolate Orange Muffins
Recipe By: From “Muffins” by Elizabeth Alston (2003)
Serving Size: 12
NOTES: If you use a mini-muffin tin, you’ll get 36.
1 cup sugar — (I used about 7/8 cup)
6 tablespoons unsalted butter — softened
2 large eggs
1/2 cup buttermilk — or plain, unsweetened yogurt
1/4 cup orange juice — freshly squeezed
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1 tablespoon orange zest — (I used about 2+ T because the oranges were large)
3 ounces semisweet chocolate — chopped in irregular small pieces
1. Preheat oven to 400° (200° C). Lightly grease a 12 cup muffin pan, or line with paper liners. May also use mini-muffin tin (if so, use shorter baking time)
2. In a medium bowl, mix flour, baking powder, and baking soda.
3. In a separate mixing bowl, with an electric mixer, cream together butter and sugar until smooth. Beat in the eggs one at a time and continue mixing until the mixture is light and ribbony. Add orange zest, orange juice, and buttermilk (or yogurt). Use a spoon to add the flour mixture and stir it in just until mixed and there are no streaks of flour. Add the chocolate pieces and stir just until combined. Divide batter into muffin cups.
4. Bake for 15 to 25 minutes in the preheated oven (to an internal temperature of 205°) or until a toothpick inserted into the center of a muffin comes out clean. Let muffins cool in the pan on a wire rack for at least 10 minutes before removing from the pan. (My batch of these took 18 minutes. Do NOT over bake them or they’ll be dry. If making ahead, reheat them gently and for a short time.)
Per Serving: 244 Calories; 9g Fat (32.3% calories from fat); 4g Protein; 38g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 51mg Cholesterol; 118mg Sodium.

hddonna
said on December 21st, 2012:
Oh, Carolyn! These look so good! I love muffins, I love chocolate and orange together, and I am definitely going to make these. Not this week–the freezer is stuffed with homemade breads and cinnamon rolls for Christmas–but as soon as I can find an excuse to do so! And I’m going to put that book on my wish list. It sounds like a real winner. Does it have a recipe for butter rum muffins, by any chance? I used to play music at a local coffee shop, which has since closed, and they served wonderful butter rum muffins. I have yet to find a recipe for them.
I’m sure there isn’t a butter rum muffin in it. Have you searched on the internet for one? My only suggestion about the choc orange muffins is that they really are best just after baking, allowed to cool for 20 minutes or so. I want to try them again with cake flour. A friend made them last week and about 3-4 hours after baking the insides were still fairly light, but the outside edges were already getting hard/stale. Even with cupcake papers. I want to make them again with some kinds of changes. But they’re fabulous as is within minutes out of the oven. Let me know how you like them. My friend used just 1 T. of orange zest it was NOT enough. Use 3 if you can. . . carolyn t