Sicilian Winter Orange & Fennel Salad

A post from Carolyn. In early December I attended my first in-person cooking class with Phillis Carey, my favorite cooking instructor. All through Covid she taught via zoom, and if I couldn’t taste the food, why bother, was my motto? After three years, it was so fun to see her (and her cooking friend Diane Phillips) and to eat a treasure-trove of new things. This was one of the recipes I really liked.
Phillis’s heritage is Sicilian, so her recipes were more Southern Italian. This salad could be made ahead up to the point of tossing it. Prep the fennel ahead and the fresh oranges (let the fennel marinate in the orange/juice to keep it from turning brown). Have the arugula part all ready to dress, and toss at the last minute.
The dressing is just slightly different – lemon juice and white wine vinegar, a tetch of honey, and EVOO. Easy to make ahead too. You may also add olives – Phillis added Kalamata, but she also suggested Castelvetrano (I’d prefer those). Your choice, however. The olives add some color to the salad in addition to a punch of flavor. Castelvetrano olives are a ripe olive, very mild, not acidic/bitter like Kalamata. Arugula is everywhere now in the grocery stores, so that wouldn’t be hard to find. You could use baby spinach, I suppose, but it wouldn’t be authentic. I may make this salad for Christmas or New Year’s Eve. One or the other. If you can find blood oranges, that would make an ever prettier platter of salad. Sometimes they’re available around the holidays. I haven’t seen them lately.
You can plate individually, or make a big platter of it with the oranges and olives and fennel piled on top of the arugula, kind of centered. If I do that for the holidays I’ll take a picture of it!!
What’s GOOD: love the acid (lemon juice/vinegar and olives) vs. sweet (honey, oranges). It’s a simple dressing, but perfect for arugula. What a pretty salad it makes. And nice that it can be made ahead up to the point of dressing it. A winner.
What’s NOT: nothing, really – easy to do.
printer-friendly PDF and MasterCook file (click link to open recipe)
* Exported from MasterCook *
Sicilian Winter Orange and Fennel Salad
Recipe By: Phillis Carey
Servings: 4
DRESSING:
2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
2 tablespoons white wine vinegar
2 tablespoons honey
1/3 cup EVOO salt and pepper to taste
SALAD:
3 whole blood oranges — or regular, or a mixture
2 cups arugula
1 whole fennel bulb — trimmed, thinly sliced
1/4 cup olives — Kalamata or Castelvetrano
NOTE: If making ahead, slice oranges and add fennel to keep fennel from turning brown. Refrigerate until ready to serve.
1. Dressing: whisk lemon juice, vinegar and honey together in a medium bowl. Whisk in EVOO and season with salt and pepper. Cover and refrigerate up to 2 days.
2. Trim off and discard peel and white pith from oranges. Slice crosswise into thin rounds and set aside. Cover and refrigerate until ready to serve.
3. Toss arugula and fennel with enough of the dressing to moisten. Arrange on a plate or platter with orange slices and olives. Drizzle with more dressing and serve.
Per Serving: 271 Calories; 19g Fat (60.8% calories from fat); 2g Protein; 26g Carbohydrate; 5g Dietary Fiber; 0mg Cholesterol; 96mg Sodium; 21g Total Sugars; 0mcg Vitamin D; 93mg Calcium; 1mg Iron; 474mg Potassium; 50mg Phosphorus.