Why should we expect recipes to turn out the same every time?

This was a question posed to Jason Hammel, a Chicago chef, in the July, 2013 issue of Food and Wine magazine. I had hoped to just link you to the article online, but alas, it doesn’t appear to BE online. So I’m going to type it out here. His answers got me to thinking . . .

I had a grandmother who could really bake. Her lard-soft pumpkin cookies would greet me at the door, always tasting exactly the same. But their consistency didn’t become a marvel until she died, and I was left to my own devices with a recipe on an index card. Not one of my batches tasted the way I remembered.

I soon realized that the recipe alone would never bring back a flavor I had lost. And it got me thinking about my life as a chef. Were recipes necessary?

In my kitchens, cooks always carry a notebook with them. Inside are lists of ingredients, reading like poetry:

leeks, melted
Riesling
goat butter
chopped dill

These become sauces and vinaigrettes. They are guides and inspirations, meant to be explored. Following a chef’s vision is what teaches young cooks to taste and learn and interact with ingredients. An over-wintered leek will not behave the same as a hot summer leek; it won’t need the same amount of wine, butter or dill. Instead of writing down measurements, we should teach how to explore the craft of cooking with our senses. When I imagine my cookbook, I see words and images, not cups and ounces.

I would write my grandmother’s cookie recipe this way:
Creamed sugar and lard
1 small can pumpkin
3 eggs
Some nutmeg
A simple frosting
Lined in parchment in red Tupperware container almost out of reach
Sun coming in from a mountain road
The cookies baked gently, remaining soft, so that they stick to your fingers and you have to lick them off, one by one.

Isn’t that just beautiful? I’ve recently finished reading a book about a chef. Kathleen Flinn’s The Sharper Your Knife, the Less You Cry: Love, Laughter, and Tears in Paris at the World’s Most Famous Cooking School. Flinn realized a dream – to attend Le Cordon Bleu in Paris. It’s a detailed story about her cooking school journey, the people she met, the chefs who sometimes ridiculed her, some who encouraged her, about the discipline required and grueling hours at the school, day after day, week after week. Trying to learn, when she didn’t speak French. She never talked about her notebook, other than she said she took copious notes during all of her classes and would transcribe them at the end of the day. There’s a recipe at the end of every chapter, usually related some to the chapter subject. She wanted to be a journalist, but in the food biz. She’s received many accolades for her book. It’s written well, and as I read it I felt she did begin using her senses rather than an exact formula, although there were some formulas that were mandatory. She graduated and did very well. And the parting word at graduation from one of her chef teachers was “Miz Fleen, taste, taste, taste.” There’s a love story woven into the book as well. Worth reading.