The Essential New York Times Cookbook – Part I in a Series
My friend Linda T and I exchange Christmas gifts each year, and we’ve gotten into the habit of giving one another a new cookbook. And this is the one she gave me this last December. What a gem it is, at 930+ pages. When I opened it she said “you’ve got to read the Introduction first – it’s really interesting.” Dutifully I did, and within a few short paragraphs I’d retrieved my little pad of pink stickies and began putting them on the recipe pages referred to in this Introduction. This section of the book is about 12 pages long and mostly gives a detailed explanation about how the book came into being, but mostly it’s about how Amanda Hesser and her assistant Merrill Stubbs accomplished the project.
It started one day in 2004 when Hesser was having lunch with a colleague at the Times. They were discussing what their next projects were. In talking over how food and recipe interests have changed over the decades a germ of an idea was born in Hesser’s head. She wanted to write a book that encompassed 150 years of the New York Times food writing (recipes). Not the time just since Craig Claiborne wrote his book, or any number of books since then. No, she wanted to go way back into the paper’s history and chronicle the best.
Her first step was to put a journalist’s query into the newspaper and the magazine, asking readers to send her a note (letter or email) about their favorite recipes published in the New York Times. She received nothing less than 6,000 replies! Yikes! It was there that she learned about Craig Claiborne’s Paella (p. 309) that took him 6 years to perfect; about Le Cirque’s Spaghetti Primavera (p. 314) that no fewer than 3 people claimed to have invented themselves; and a Forget-It Meringue Torte (p. 823) a meringue cake that “billows like a jib in the oven.”
The respondents mentioned recipes having saved marriages, or reminded them of their lost youth, or something that symbolized family gatherings. Once the list had been collated (on an elaborate spreadsheet, obviously) there were 145 single-spaced pages of recipe suggestions. Four of the top five recipes were desserts (in a couple of days I’ll share with you the #1 recipe – the most frequently requested recipe at the newspaper.
Those top 5 recipes are (and if you’re anxious to know about each recipe, just click the link – I found all of them online, but not necessarily from the New York Times’ website):
Purple Plum Torte (265 votes; p. 763)
David Eyre’s Pancakes (80 votes; p. 813)
Teddie’s Apple Cake (37 votes; p. 752)
Chocolate Dump-It Cake (24 votes; p. 781) and
Ed Giobbi’s Lasagna (23 votes; but the Lasagna on p. 342 edged out this winner)
For two full years, Amanda and Merrill began cooking together in the evenings to test the 400 recipes that they culled from the list. A few times each week they’d gather at Amanda’s home, cook, test, note-take, serve dinner about 10:30. The 3 of them (including Amanda’s husband) would weigh in on each dish and recipes were tweaked and adjusted until they got them just right. So, that 2-year stint covered the years from about 1950 to about 2004. Along the way they observed that we sort of stopped making extravagant desserts. We learned how to cook pasta correctly and how to sauce it properly. We also learned about roasting vegetables. We also left German food (mostly) behind, and we “largely failed to adopt Chinese cooking at home.” Yup.
The Introduction includes some very interesting food-related timelines, starting with 1860, when the first refrigerated car carrying strawberries were transported on the Illinois Central Railroad. In the 1920’s White Castle promoted hamburgers and its cleanliness. By minimizing its seating area, the chain established the notion of “take-out.” In 1930 the Boston Oyster House at the Morrison Hotel in Chicago popularized its “salad bar,” a concept that really didn’t catch on until the 70’s.
She assumed some readers would be mightily upset that their favorites weren’t included in the cookbook (including a recipe for “clams possilipo” that eluded the searchers – nobody could find the original recipe – so I assume they couldn’t include it because they couldn’t actually prove it was published in the Times), but Amanda hoped the inclusion of Cucumbers in Cream (p. 225) and Fontainebleau (a kind of dessert cheese, p. 829) would make up for it.
This is Part I of this series. Tomorrow I’ll tell you about the next stage of the cookbook writing. It’s just as interesting. If you are motivated to buy the book, here’s the link. It’s a bargain at $23.52 at Amazon.com: The Essential New York Times Cookbook: Classic Recipes for a New Century.
As a result of Amanda’s and Merrill’s collaboration on this cookbook, (they’re now business partners too) they have a blog called Food52, in case you’re interested in following their food travels.