The Essential New York Times Cook Book (Part II of a series)
As I explained yesterday, my friend Linda gave me this cookbook for Christmas. I’ve been so intrigued by not only the 12-page introduction to the book, but I’ve yellow-stickied about 40-50 recipes in it so far, and I’m only about a third of the way through.
Yesterday I posted the initial story about the Introduction. Here’s the continuing saga . . . the final phase of compiling recipes for this 1,104 recipe book (932 pages long), after she’d tested 400 recipe recommendations from readers (that took 2 years), and tested another 400 recipes spanning the 1850-1950 range, was to research the Dining section of every issue and the Magazine food columns too. She’s glad she did, because she added lots of other recipes to the book, including favorites like Stuck-Pot Rice with Yogurt and Spices (p. 351), Thomas Keller’s Gazpacho (p. 146), and Tangerine Sherbet (p. 734). Numerous stories about Craig Claiborne had her reading recipes from these other sources. In about 1974 Claiborne began cooking with Pierre Franey – once a week the two men would cook in Claiborne’s kitchen at his home in the Hamptons. Franey did the cooking and Claiborne sat at his trusty IBM Selectric typewriter and made notes which went into the weekly column. As the story goes, the parties they threw there were legendary, including the one where so many people stood on Claiborne’s deck that it collapsed.
New, up and coming chefs’ names began appearing in the paper – Alice Waters, Emeril Legasse, and then Mark Bittman. As Amanda read the recipes she tried to provide balance in the cookbook – the book couldn’t be all Osso Buco and chocolate mousse, so she added recipes for Oriental Watercress Soup (p. 111), Charleston Coconut Sweeties (p. 683) and Tuna Curry (p. 435), for instance.
Her test for whether a recipe would go in the book was simple: once she made it, would she make it again? In making sure she made raspberry granita 3 times, baked Teddie’s apple cake 4+ times, and she made stewed fennel at least 6 times.
Amanda does explain that almost none of the recipes originated at the New York Times. They were someone else’s recipe –whether it was Aunt Mable’s poundcake or a famous chef’s rendition of Cornish game hen. She phrases it thus: the newspaper was just a waystation for recipes, which pass through on their way from chefs and home cooks to readers. Therefore the archive (the cookbook) is a mish-mash of traditional, innovative and everything in between.
She notes, though, that in the process or writing the book several significant things changed:
- The main improvement has been intensity of flavor. Recipes are much more aggressively seasoned now, with layers of herbs and spices.
- Cayenne was the only chile-based heat up until about 1970; chiles, in many varieties, are now commonplace.
- Meats, especially chicken, cook nearly twice as fast as they did 100 years ago because animals are raised more quickly and exercise less, which renders their meat more tender.
- Egg yolks have either shrunk or lost their binding strength – old custard recipes that called for 3 yolks generally needed 5 to 6 “modern” egg yolks to set.
Sometimes she left the language of the day in the recipe. Other times she had to update the instructions or she added Notes for clarity. I just love reading Amanda’s notes – not only is she a very good writer, but she’s interesting and finds humor in the kitchen. Some recipes contain no headnotes, others contain a lengthy one. A few recipes include comments left by readers, or from the 6,000 responses she received to her query. They often suggest other changes they’ve made. Each and every recipe includes the date, origin of the recipe and the title of the column. What there is not in this cookbook are photographs of any of the food. With 1,104 recipes, it would have been a Herculean task to photograph them all as well as test them. I do love photos of the food, but the written word will give you a pretty good clue as to whether you want to tackle a recipe.
Needless to say, I’ve been very impressed with the cookbook. So far I’ve made just a couple of the recipes in the book – the Summer-Squash Casserole I made a couple of weeks ago was one of them. It was sensational. Next on my radar is to try the 1948 recipe for Green Goddess dressing. Stay tuned tomorrow – I’m going to give you the recipe for the number one requested dessert, the Purple Plum Torte.
This is Part II of this series. If you are motivated to buy the book, here’s the link. It’s a bargain at $23.52 at Amazon.com: The Essential New York Times Cookbook: Classic Recipes for a New Century.
As a result of Amanda’s and Merrill’s collaboration on this cookbook, (they’re now business partners too) they have a blog called Food52, in case you’re interested in following their food travels.