Butter and Herb Roasted Red Onions

Talk about sweet! Talk about unusual! Talk about how BIG these are on a plate! All of the above. I’ve had this recipe in my to-try file for a long time (it’s from a December, 2007 Bon Appétit article).

Pictured left, the progression:

Onion: I used medium-sized red onions. One per person. Very carefully I sliced off the root end, but left it still intact.

Then I turned it over and cut off the other end, just enough so you could see some of the fleshy onion inside. That gave me edges to grab to try to peel it. It was easier than you might think once you do the next step.

Then I used a very sharp knife and cut (scored, really) the outside of the onion in four places, like you would an orange. Not deep – just enough so I could get ahold of the skin of the onion to remove it.

Then the onion was actually cut down close to the root – the recipe said cut into six wedges – I did eight. Note you do not cut down through the root. And DO leave about 1/2 inch of the onion uncut nearest the root. That way maybe the onion won’t open up (bloom) quite so much.

Place the onions, on foil, on a rimmed baking sheet.

Oven: Preheat it to 400°.

The butter baste: Meanwhile you melt butter, add herbs and lemon juice, and slather about half of it on the onions with a kitchen/pastry brush. Much of it will leak out the bottom, so don’t overdo it. I used less butter than the recipe called for, and I basted the onions twice during its one hour baking time. Do be sure to put the rack in the middle (or even slightly lower) in your oven. Too high and the onion tops will singe too much from the reflected heat.

It happened that I made these an hour or two before our guests arrived, so when the doorbell rang I placed the pan back in the oven at low heat just to re-warm them.

The results: marvelous. And really very easy. All four of us slicked them up. The onions turn so sweet once they’re roasted. And the lemon butter with herbs was perfect with it. You might make extras because I’m sure they would reheat very well.

printer-friendly PDF

Butter- and Herb-Roasted Red Onions

Recipe By: Adapted from a recipe in Bon Appetit, 2007
Serving Size: 6
NOTES: Bon Appetit’s test kitchen added notes: This simple recipe has endless variations. Here are three to try: After they come out of the oven, top the onions with a little crumbled blue cheese, sprinkle a mixture of crumbled cooked bacon and grated Parmesan on top, or whisk a little Dijon mustard and garlic into the herb butter before starting. The onions open up like a chrysanthemum once it’s baked – the deeper you make the cuts in the onion, the more open and wide the onion will be.

6 medium red onions — (about 7 ounces each) peeled, cut vertically into 8 wedges to within 1/2 inch of bottom
1/3 cup butter — (1 stick)
4 teaspoons fresh rosemary — minced fine
1 tablespoon fresh Italian parsley — chopped
2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice

1. Position rack in center of oven; preheat to 400°F.
2. Place onions on rimmed baking sheet and line with foil. Open onion wedges to resemble flowers but do not break off base.
3. Melt butter in small saucepan over low heat. Whisk in rosemary, parsley, and lemon juice. Season herb butter with salt and pepper. Brush some butter over onions.
4. Roast onions until tender and beginning to char, brushing occasionally with more herb butter, about 1 hour. Serve warm.
Per Serving: 152 Calories; 10g Fat (59.5% calories from fat); 2g Protein; 14g Carbohydrate; 3g Dietary Fiber; 28mg Cholesterol; 109mg Sodium.

A year ago: Tomato Corn Pie with Biscuit Crust
Two years ago: I wrote a little called  dear slot machine when we were in Las Vegas (in honor of my mother who carefully chose which slot machine she’d play and won on a regular basis)
Three years ago: Peach Raspberry Streusel Cake