Old-Fashioned Creamy Lemon Pudding

Last weekend we had a 3-hour choir rehearsal on Saturday morning. And that night we planned an impromptu dinner for family and friends. No planning went into it, really, other than I defrosted a big piece of salmon. My dear DH went grocery shopping for me while I started in on making some sides. I’m going to write up a separate post about those. Almost all of them were things I’ve made before, and knew were easy to throw together. My friend Cherrie brought an appetizer and a side dish too, which really helped. I could have just served ice cream for dessert (store bought – I didn’t think I had time to make some) but luckily I found one dessert recipe in my to-try file that I thought would be easy and good. We still have a few Meyer lemons on our trees here, so making lemon pudding seemed like a perfect fit.


The recipe came from a 2005 Sunset magazine article – a recipe submitted by Sandra Krist. She used to make the full-on crust and this as a filling, but decided it was a lot less trouble to just make pudding instead.

It’s a buttermilk based pudding, but it’s made more like a sauce since it’s thickened with flour, cornstarch AND eggs. It does have a bit of graininess from the flour (there’s 2 tablespoons in a 2-cup buttermilk batch). Cornstarch doesn’t usually produce any graininess, so I’m assuming it was from the flour. It didn’t detract from the pudding – just makes for a slightly different texture.

As the originator says, because of the buttermilk, it has a bit of tang to it. We all liked that aspect a lot. It is similar to lemon curd, but with a lot less butter – well, and the buttermilk.  First you combine the flour, cornstarch and sugar, then you add the cold buttermilk. I used one of those older-style up-down whisks to mash out

all of the lumps before I started cooking it. I noticed that as soon as it started to heat up, the flour started to clump. (Another option would be to combine the ingredients in a blender, then you could avoid all the whisking, I think.) I kept up the up-down whisk motion (with help from granddaughter Taylor) throughout the cooking. If you have a ball-bearing type whisk, that would work too.

Eventually it comes to a slow simmer. Then you temper the eggs (by adding some of the hot pudding to the eggs, mixing, then pouring that into the pan for further cooking) and you add fresh lemon juice, lemon peel and butter. Continue cooking until the mixture reaches 160° and thickly coats a spoon. Don’t boil it, though, or the eggs will scramble.

For my purposes I thought individual ramekins would be best, so I used a large ladle to pour in the hot pudding. They cooled on the kitchen counter, then I covered them with plastic wrap and chilled them. I made some sweetened whipped cream to spoon on top. And a single mint leaf garnished the cream. I tripled the recipe and had some leftover after making 6-ounce ramekin servings, so I think each 2-cup buttermilk recipe would serve 5 people. Results: very good. Not as tart/piquant perhaps as lemon curd, but it shouldn’t be – as a pudding – or it would be too rich to eat by itself (without a crust or tart shell). Everybody slicked up their bowl, even our son-in-law who professes to not like lemon.

printer-friendly PDF

Old-Fashioned Creamy Lemon Pudding

Recipe By: Sandra Krist, in Sunset, 2005
Serving Size: 4-5

2 large eggs
1 cup sugar
3 tablespoons cornstarch
2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
2 cups buttermilk
1/2 teaspoon grated lemon peel
1/3 cup fresh lemon juice
1/4 cup butter
Lightly sweetened whipped cream, optional

1. In a bowl, whisk eggs to blend. Set aside.
2. In a 2- to 3-quart pan, mix sugar, cornstarch, and flour. Stir in the buttermilk. Use a whisk to dissolve all the dry lumps before starting to cook. Set the mixture over medium heat and stir often until simmering, 10 to 12 minutes. Continue simmering, stirring often, 2 minutes longer.
3. Whisk half the buttermilk mixture into the eggs, then return both to pan, along with lemon peel, lemon juice, and butter. Whisk over medium-low heat until pudding reaches 160° on an instant-read thermometer and very thickly coats a spoon, 4 to 6 minutes; do not boil.
4. Spoon pudding into bowls or heatproof glasses. Serve warm or cool, with whipped cream if desired.
Per Serving: 424 Calories; 15g Fat (31.4% calories from fat); 8g Protein; 66g Carbohydrate; trace Dietary Fiber; 141mg Cholesterol; 282mg Sodium.

One year ago: Roasted Peach Ice Cream
Two years ago: Cold Watermelon Blueberry Soup
Three years ago: Baby Backs with Peanut Butter Slather (haven’t made these since then, but I remember how great they were)