Filet Mignon with Mushroom Port Sauce

fillet mignon wine mushroom sauceOh my. Yum. Wow. Delicious. Any other superlatives you need to read before you try this? Definitely a meal worthy of a special evening. Like Valentine’s Day. Or a birthday. Or an anniversary. Naturally, just buying filet mignon is enough of an expense so you want to make the preparation worthy of the price, right?

fillet mignon cut If you use this method of searing the meat, then baking it, you’re assured of an evenly-cooked piece of beef. I never knew how restaurants managed to do that. When my DH used to just grill it on the barbecue, straight over the coals, you only had a center strip that was nice and juicy red. Now we’re able to get them to have a nice brown crusty edge and a perfectly cooked pink, or rare piece of steak.

The sauce is mostly composed of mushrooms, but accented with both red wine, port wine, shallots, some beef broth, and a touch of cream. Oh yes, a bit of olive oil and butter too.

fillet mignonSo, there’s a shot of the filets at left. All I’d done at this point was sear them in a medium-hot nonstick skillet for about 2 minutes per side. I also briefly seared them on the two long sides as well. Just because they look prettier that way. So the meat is totally raw inside at this point. I placed them on a Silpat-lined small baking sheet and they went into a 400 oven for about 7-8 minutes. How long they bake depends on how thick the filets are –  mine were truly thick. If they’re not so, then 5-6 minutes will probably do it. But whatever you do, use a meat thermometer and take them OUT of the oven when they reach about 123° to 125°. They’ll continue to rise in temp just sitting on your kitchen counter while you finish up the sauce and serving. Ideally, tent them for 3-5 minutes to allow the juices to be reabsorbed. I put my dinner plates into the hot oven at that point and watched them carefully. But I definitely wanted to serve these premium filets on hot plates.

Meanwhile, while the steaks were baking, I whipped up the sauce. Just make certain you have everything all prepped before you start – you won’t have time to cut or dice, or measure anything. The shallots are sautéed a bit, sliced mushrooms are added and sautéed for several minutes, then you add the port and red wine and stir and let it bubble away until the liquid has reduced way down. Then you add the beef broth and simmer that until it’s reduced down some. Then a tad of Dijon mustard is added, along with some heavy cream and you’re done.

The recipe came from a cooking class with Phillis Carey – probably several years ago. A very good recipe, and perfect for guests. We bought these filets frozen from a home-delivery meat company last week, so I was anxious to try them. Oh were they ever tender. Probably could have cut them with a fork. Almost. And this preparation was just delish.
printer-friendly PDF

Fillet Mignons with Mushroom Port Sauce

Recipe By: Phillis Carey, from a cooking class
Serving Size: 4

3 tablespoons olive oil
24 ounces fillet mignon — 1 1/2 inches thick, 4 slices
SAUCE:
3 tablespoons unsalted butter
3 tablespoons shallots — minced
1/2 pound button mushrooms — sliced
1/3 cup port wine — Tawny variety
2/3 cup dry red wine — Merlot or Cab preferred
1 cup beef broth
1 1/2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
1/2 cup heavy cream
1/2 cup parsley — minced, for garnish

1. Preheat oven to 400. For fillets, heat 2 T. of oil in a heavy skillet over medium-high heat until hot, but not smoking. Season steaks with salt and pepper and sear on each side for about 2 minutes. Transfer meat to a baking sheet and roast the filets for 5-6 minutes until medium rare. Ideally, use a probe thermometer and remove the steaks exactly when they reach 125 degrees F for medium rare. Rare is about 120. The meat will rise in temp after it’s removed from the oven – tent gently with foil if the sauce isn’t quite ready – allowing meat to sit for about 5 minutes before serving on very hot plates.
2. SAUCE: Pour off any fat remaining in the skillet and add the remaining olive oil and butter. Saute the shallots until tender, about 2 minutes. Add the mushrooms and cook until softened, about 4 minutes.
3. Add the port and red wine and boil until mixture is reduced by about 2/3. Add the beef broth and boil until it is reduced by half. Use a wire whisk to add the mustard. It will clump up if not whisked in carefully and quickly. Bring to a boil and whisk in any juices that accumulated with the steak and season with salt and pepper if needed. Serve sauce spooned over each steak. Garnish with parsley.
Per Serving: 842 Calories; 69g Fat (77.7% calories from fat); 35g Protein; 9g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 184mg Cholesterol; 470mg Sodium.

A year ago: Gorgonzola, Grape & Pine Nut Crostini
Two years ago: Orzo Carbonara