Potato & Romaine Salad with Creamy Dijon Dressing

potato romaine saladIt may be a long time since I’d made this – as long as 14 years ago. On the day that our daughter, Dana, was married in our backyard. About 50 people were invited and having a catered lunch was just not in the cards. So I elicited help from family and friends to help with the last-minute food prep to serve a nice lunch buffet. I served a Cornish game hen salad that had been a favorite (still is), and this salad. In this dish we covered salad and carbs all in one.

Once Dana & Todd said their vows, we served shrimp & avocado salsa to keep everyone’s tummies under control. It was a very, very hot September day. My treasured punch bowl broke when we served the punch – I’d placed the bowl on a table outside and it sat in the sun for about 4-5 minutes before I poured the iced punch into the bowl. I heard the crack. And shortly thereafter, all the punch dribbled out the bottom of the bowl, all over the tablecloth and all over the patio. Sigh. I’ve never replaced the punch bowl. Thought about it, but haven’t.

Ideally this dish is made with red-skinned potatoes, but I had some of those new baby potatoes on hand – they’re called “teeny tiny potatoes.” The recipe came from Bon Appétit, way back in 1994. The recipe is available online, and some people who made it thought the dressing was too heavy and oily. Indeed, if you poured all the dressing onto the potatoes it might be – but I never have. I always have dressing left over, so keep that in mind. I’ve added another tablespoon of vinegar to the mix – I like it better myself.

A secret, if there is one, to this recipe is pouring apple cider vinegar over the hot potatoes. As with many absorbent carbs (like beans and potatoes), they benefit from a lot of acid. I have a sensational bean salad that I make that has almost no oil in it – all vinegar. The beans soak up the acid, and somehow the starch in the bean just neutralizes the vinegar. Don’t know how or why that works, but it does. This recipe works much the same way. You can leave the potatoes out at room temp for up to 4 hours, so it’s just a matter of making the Romaine salad part, tossing dressing on the potatoes, spreading them on top of the salad, then sprinkling capers on top.

I had leftovers after serving this, so I removed the Romaine and saved the all-dressed potatoes. The next night I made a more traditional green salad (Romaine, radishes, red cabbage only) and piled the potatoes on top. I also dressed the entire salad with the Dijon dressing too. I liked it better.

You can prepare the dressing up to a day ahead; just bring it to room temp before tossing it on the potatoes. I like this dish because it covers both salad and carbs – all in one. The dressing is a mustard-rich one – you definitely can taste more than a hint of the mustard. If you don’t like mustard, tone it down a bit. This salad can be taken to a picnic. Is great for a hot summer night.
printer-friendly PDF

Potato & Romaine Salad with Creamy Dijon Dressing

Recipe: Bon Appetit, April, 1994
Servings: 6
Note: you can also add red cabbage and radishes to the green salad (use sturdy types) to augment the salad, rather than just Romaine.

3 tablespoons Dijon mustard
2 tablespoons water
2 tablespoon white wine vinegar
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon pepper — ground
1 1/4 cups olive oil — extra virgin
2 tablespoons whipping cream — chilled
2 tablespoons fresh basil — chopped fine
1 tablespoon fresh parsley — chopped
2 pounds potatoes — red-skinned
5 tablespoons cider vinegar
1/4 cup olive oil — extra virgin
2 tablespoons white wine vinegar
1 head romaine lettuce — coarsely chopped
2 tablespoons capers — drained

1. Dressing: Blend mustard, water, vinegar, salt, pepper in food processor. With machine running, add oil in slow, steady stream. Add cream; blend mixture until thick and creamy. Mix in herbs and pulse briefly. Can be prepared ahead one day. Cover & refrigerate. Bring to room temperature before using, thinning with water if dressing becomes too thick.
2. Salad: Cook potatoes in large pot of boiling water until tender, about 30 minutes. Drain and cool. Peel potatoes and cut into 1/3 inch thick slices. Transfer potatoes to large bowl. Sprinkle with cider vinegar. Can be made 4 hours ahead. Let stand at room temperature.
3. Whisk oil and vinegar in another large bowl. Add lettuce and toss to coat. Add capers to potatoes. Mix enough dressing into potatoes to coat. Spoon potatoes on top of romaine leaves and serve. You will not need all of the dressing.
Per Serving (assumes you use all the dressing): 643 Calories; 57g Fat (76.9% calories from fat); 6g Protein; 32g Carbohydrate; 5g Dietary Fiber; 7mg Cholesterol; 497mg Sodium.

A year ago: Cornish Game Hen Salad
Two years ago: Sicilian Tuna Salad