Trout Fillets with Mayo Caper Topping

trout fillets with mayonnaise caper topping

My history with trout goes way back. I believe I told the story here before that when I was young (between about age 5-12) my family always went tent camping for our annual summer vacation. We camped in the California Sierras – Virginia Lakes, sometimes on the Sonora (west) side, but most often on the eastern side in a variety of campgrounds. My dad made plans a year ahead as to which campground we’d go to. My mom planned for weeks ahead, thinking about what meals she’d prepare on the kerosene camp stove (two burners) usually three meals a day. Because there wasn’t much to do there, food played a vital role in the entertainment. But for many, many meals we ate the trout my dad (and sometimes my mother or I) caught in the rivers and lakes.

My mom had only one way she prepared the trout – dipped whole (tail and head intact, including the eyes of course, which for me was a big yuk factor) in egg, cornmeal and pan fried in bacon grease (leftover from the bacon and egg breakfasts we ate every morning in the chilly filtered light coming through the pine trees, with a stream gurgling nearby – the stream lulled me to sleep every night, and I’ve never forgotten that sound).

But, we ate trout. And more trout. And more trout. So much trout that after about 3 days of it I couldn’t eat another bite. My mother either. Even my dad tired of eating trout. We even had to eat it for breakfast some mornings. More yuk. But what I disliked the most were the bones. And I’ve never wavered in my aversion to fish bones. I never, ever order fish at a restaurant unless it’s a boneless fillet. And usually I’ll discuss the bones with the waiter/waitress to make sure somebody has paid close attention to the removal of them.

Yet I do enjoy the flavor – the delicate flavor – of trout. So, the other evening we had dinner at a restaurant some miles from our home, and the waitress happened to mention that her son often catches fresh trout near Mammoth Lakes and brings them home to her. But she doesn’t like trout. Won’t eat it. Would we like some, she asked? Free. She wanted to get it out of her freezer. Sure, we said. My DH met her at the restaurant the next day and she happily handed him two freezer bags of trout fillets. I did have to use needle-nosed pliers to remove about another 40-50 pin bones from the 5-7 fillets in the first bag. Even one of those would have ruined the dinner for me.

Because this trout was already filleted, I couldn’t have prepared it in my mother’s tried and true method. So I baked the slim fillets with a mayo based topping. It took but a few minutes to cook them through. The resulting fish was tender and moist from the topping. And the flavor was mostly hidden, actually, from the strong flavors of capers and the Pecorino cheese. I might have liked to taste more of the fish, so if you prefer the fish flavor I’d recommend you eliminate the capers and use a milder cheese. In any case, the preparation takes little time and the mayo sauce is quite forgiving if you lack one thing or another in the recipe. This isn’t a wow recipe. My DH didn’t care for it much, but he thought it was the fish, not the preparation. But I had not one single bone!
printer-friendly PDF

Trout Fillets with Mayo-Caper Topping

Serving Size: 4

3/4 pound trout fillet — skinned, deboned, patted dry
1/3 cup mayonnaise
1 1/2 tablespoons capers
1 1/2 tablespoons Dijon mustard — with tarragon
1/2 whole onion – finely minced
1/4 cup Pecorino cheese – or Parmigiano-Reggiano

1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees F.
2. In a small bowl combine the mayo, capers and mustard. Stir to combine. With a spreader knife, spread less than half of the mayo mixture on the bottom of each trout fillet. Place in a Silpat or parchment lined pan, mayo side down. Use remaining mayo mixture to cover the tops of all the fillets. Sprinkle the minced onion on top, then sprinkle each fillet with the grated Pecorino cheese.
3. Bake fillets for 10 minutes. Serve with a colorful vegetable (broccoli, asparagus, zucchini) and a simple vinaigrette-dressed salad.
Per Serving: 281 Calories; 22g Fat (70.1% calories from fat); 19g Protein; 2g Carbohydrate; trace Dietary Fiber; 59mg Cholesterol; 242mg Sodium.