Broccoli Casserole


This is an oldie. But a goodie. It used to be a regular on my holiday menu – whether it be Easter, Thanksgiving or Christmas. Or even just for a dinner for guests. I’ve made it with fresh broccoli (like this time), but hey, it tastes just great with frozen chopped broccoli. So if you don’t feel like fussing with fresh, you’ll not be disappointed using frozen chopped. I decided to post it, in case you’re thinking about some easy, but different casserole to make for Easter dinner. It can be prepared ahead and popped in the oven when dinner is close. My recollection is this recipe came from an ancient Sunset Magazine. I searched their website but couldn’t find it. I got it from a distant relative, Gerry Black, a loo-ooo-ng time ago. But it’s weathered the ages. Well.

Somehow, we’ve gotten out of the habit of making cream sauce. Well, you know, maybe it’s not so good for us, especially if you use butter and cream. But, this one CAN be made with non-fat milk and a bit less butter if you want. It calls for mayo, so you can use non-fat mayo (Veganaise works well here_ if you want. So, you may alter the recipe any way it suits you.

There’s the dish, L-R: Mixing in the broccoli to the cream sauce; in the hot water bath ready to go in the oven; easy serving right out of the casserole.

A note about the onion. I think I’ve mentioned here on this blog before, that when I was a young woman and still learning to cook (this, when I was in my 20’s) I was a bit loose with the herbs and spices. I figured that if a teaspoon of thyme (one of my favorite herbs, still is) was good, then 2 teaspoons would be better. It probably worked fine with thyme, maybe not so well with curry powder. Time, age and humility have set in, though. I now use what the recipe calls for first. THEN, if I want to, I’ll diddle with the proportions. Hence with this and the onion. The original called for about a tablespoon of onion. Well, I don’t know about you and onions, but with me — who uses a tablespoon of onion, for heaven’s sake? So, I started using more. But then I noticed that it tasted more like an onion casserole with a green veggie in it, instead of a broccoli casserole. That’s the humbling part of it – I learned that this recipe really doesn’t like tons of onion in it. So be gentle. But I’ll tell you that the mayo is an important component – don’t skimp on it, be it full fat or low or non. Of course, it makes it delicious.
printer-friendly CutePDF and MasterCook file (click link to open recipe)

Broccoli Casserole

Recipe By : Gerry Black, via Sunset Mag, probably about 1970
Serving Size : 6

NOTES : This can be made with egg substitutes, non-fat mayo and less butter, and it’s still quite tasty, but this is close to the original recipe (I added more onion). I also add just a tiny sprinkling of nutmeg to the cream sauce.

10 ounces chopped broccoli, frozen
3 tablespoons butter
3 tablespoons flour
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 dash pepper
1 dash nutmeg
1 cup milk
1/4 cup onion — minced (very finely minced)
3/4 cup mayonnaise
3 whole eggs — beaten

1. Preheat oven to 350°F. Cook broccoli in a little water until barely done. Drain and set aside. Meanwhile, make a white sauce: in a saucepan melt the butter, add flour, salt, pepper and then milk all at once. Stir until thickened. Add the mayo, onion and eggs. Gently stir in the broccoli and pour into a buttered baking dish.
2. Place that pan in a larger pan of hot water and bake for 30-45 minutes (depends on how deep the dish is), until knife inserted in the middle comes out clean. It may still be a little jiggly, but if the knife comes out clean it will continue cooking for several minutes.
Per Serving: 251 Calories; 24g Fat (83.3% calories from fat); 5g Protein; 6g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 101mg Cholesterol; 278mg Sodium.

A year ago: Bailey’s (Irish Cream) Cream Cheese Brownies (very rich, very sweet)
Two years ago: Warm Bean & Brie Dip (very easy, a quite delish)