Oh gosh, you’re going to love this bread. Or cake. Or cake made in a bread pan, masquerading as a loaf bread. Whatever it is, it’s marvelous. Easy. And better than any banana bread I’ve ever made, and I thought I had a really great one!
My radar wasn’t fixed – I mean tuned in – to making banana bread. Hadn’t even thought about it. Until I got an email from a new friend, Jerianne. A friend I’ve made as a result of my blog. This new friend lives about 25 miles from me, but we met for lunch several weeks ago. She’d found my blog somehow – I don’t recall if she told me how she happened to find it, and she started reading and she emailed me about getting together. We really enjoyed talking. We have many common interests besides food. We are of a somewhat similar age. She loves to cook. We talked all about my blog, how and why, and we talked food for it seemed like hours. We’ve agreed to get together again sometime soon. She’s a Christian too, and she said a lovely prayer over our lunch.
Here’s a photo of Jerianne and me (J’s on the right) the day she took me to lunch (thank you again, Jerianne!). A week or so went by and Jerianne sent me an email with this recipe attached, telling me that I really, really needed to try this banana bread. She thought it was one of the best she’d ever made. Well, and it was called a prize-winning one, so why wouldn’t it be special? When I saw bananas, some very ripe ones, at the market, they called out to me and I made this bread. Oh my. Yes, yes, yes!
The recipe is in several places on the internet, and attributed to a county fair winner in 1981. It contains the standard stuff for a banana bread, with an addition of sour cream. I had light sour cream in my refrigerator, and it worked just fine. The bread also contains a lot of bananas – to get 1 1/2 cups I needed 4 medium sized ones. If you have really large bananas, probably 3 would be enough to measure 1 1/2 cups. My advice: measure!
It was all mixed up in my stand mixer and poured into a GREASED loaf pan. I had a bit too much for my loaf pan (fill the pan about 3/4 full), so I had to pour some of the batter into a smaller one (which I gave as a gift to our friend Joe who stayed with us the other night – Yvette, did you like it?). Likely you could scale down this recipe by about 1/5 and have just the right amount. It’s pretty hard to do that with standard measurements, but it could be done.
Then, you sprinkle raw sugar (turbinado) on the top of the raw batter – it adds a lovely crispy top. Don’t not do that step as you’ll be forever changed about adding that to any loaf breads. Loved it. The baking times varied a bit – some said 45 minutes, some an hour. I know loaf breads needed to bake until they reach about 205°, and it took about 55 minutes to do that. The bread MUST stay in the pan for a little while. Why? It’s a very, VERY tender bread/cake, and it could easily stick. If you want to be sure about this, put buttered parchment paper on the bottom of the bread pan. The large pan came out perfectly, but the little one was a little harder – it left a little bit stuck to the bottom.
After about 20 minutes I gently shook both pans to make sure the breads were loose and very carefully rolled the pan over onto my other hand and forearm, then quickly but gently placed it on a cooling rack. Be extra careful doing that – I very nearly broke the loaf in half. When I tell you it’s tender, it’s really, really tender, okay? Allow it to cool completely before slicing. Jerianne, thank you SO much for sharing this recipe with me! It’s a real winner.
What’s good: every single, solitary thing about this is wonderful. A definite do again bread.
What’s not: nothing whatsoever. What a lovely gift it would make, too.
printer-friendly PDF and MasterCook file (click link to open recipe)
* Exported from MasterCook *
Prize Winning Banana Bread
Recipe By: Adapted slightly from a 1981 county fair winner, found at grouprecipes.com
Serving Size: 18
1/2 cup butter — softened
1/4 cup vegetable oil
1 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar
2 large eggs
1 1/2 cups bananas — mashed ripe (I used 4 ripened bananas)
1/2 cup sour cream — (I used light sour cream)
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
3/4 cup walnuts — chopped
turbinado (raw) sugar for top of batter
Note: To be safe, line the bottom of the loaf pans with buttered parchment paper – for sure you’ll have no difficulty getting the bread out. Remove paper once you have removed the breads from the pans.
1. With a mixer combine butter, oil, sugars and eggs until smooth.
2. Add mashed bananas, sour cream and vanilla, stirring together well.
3. Mix in flour, baking soda and salt, stirring until it is blended. Do not over mix. Add walnuts if you’re using them and stir until combined.
4. Pour into a well-greased standard large loaf pan to about 3/4 full. It may require a second smaller pan, or use 2-3 smaller pans.
5. Sprinkle turbinado/raw sugar generously over top of batter, using your hand to gently pat some of it into the batter.
6. Bake at 325° F – large loaf pan will require about 1 hour, smaller loaves about 45 minutes or until the center of the loaf reaches 205° on an instant read thermometer.
7. Allow bread to cool in pans for about 20 minutes, then run a sharp knife around the edges, tap the pan on the counter several times or gently shake it to loosen it, (you’re trying to loosen the bread from the bottom of the pan), then invert pan over a wire rack and let the bread fall onto the rack to finish cooling completely.
8. Variations and Suggestions: Add any of the following – miniature chocolate chips, toffee bits, shredded coconut, chopped pecans or macadamia nuts.
9. Try toasting the banana bread – spread hot toasted bread with butter and even add a sprinkling of cinnamon and sugar and some slices of banana, or top with a combination of honey and peanut butter, or spread hot toasted bread with some Nutella…the possibilities are endless!
10. Use slices of banana bread to make your French toast. Just dust the finished product with some powdered sugar, or a little powdered sugar glaze, or spread on some Nutella, and maple syrup is good on it, too.
Per Serving: 253 Calories; 13g Fat (45.9% calories from fat); 4g Protein; 31g Carbohydrate; 1g Dietary Fiber; 40mg Cholesterol; 195mg Sodium.

Mary Ann
said on November 11th, 2013:
I live in South Florida & grow several varieties of banana trees so I have made A LOT of banana bread over the years. Recently, I was looking for a super moist recipe and came across this one. I have to tell you, this is BY FAR the BEST banana bread I have EVER tasted! I doubled the recipe & made two, large loaves. I froze one for some day when I want something indulgent and don’t have time to make it – now I’m even more happy I made that second loaf!
I’m so glad, Mary Ann. It is a really great recipe. All the credit goes to my friend who forwarded it to me. . . carolyn t
Charlotte Moore
said on December 9th, 2013:
I made 6 small loaves and 6 muffins from this recipe. I just took the muffins from the oven. They smell so good. I read the recipe wrong and added 1/2 cup oil. I did cut the sugar to 3/4 cups. Oops!! I also did not notice to sprinkle the sugar on top. Oh well!!
I just ate a hot muffin. WOW!!! It was so light and airy. I am not even real fond of banana bread but wanted to use up some bananas. VERY GOOD!!!
Well, it sounds like even with the little mistakes, they turned out well. I’m glad. It’s a good recipe; i agree! . . . carolyn t
Jordasche Kingston
said on December 25th, 2013:
My problem with banana bread is it is always too dry. Not this version! Just pulled out of the oven 20 minutes ago, and had a slice with butter. Wow!!! So delicious! And not dry! Thank you so much for sharing.
You’re so welcome. It’s a great recipe; I agree . . . carolyn t
Cindy
said on January 28th, 2014:
Excellent banana bread, very moist and great flavor! Will make my regular recipe from now on!
Great! So glad you liked it as much as we did! . . .carolyn t
Keekle
said on July 7th, 2014:
Added chocolate chips and get so many compliments! Even the 20 somethings said it was better than their aunt’s! Thank you and your friend for sharing!
So glad you liked it. It’s my go-to from here on out! . . .carolyn t
Shari
said on December 22nd, 2014:
Been looking for that moist delious muffin recipie for my banana bear pan…over sized muffins.
Banana bread … for years iv’e used the same recipe and altered to my liking, but felt I needed a freash start…I currently have mini muffins with nuts and chips per my daughters request. A small loaf and a full loaf all out of one mix…I thought I lost track of flour, so I added another 1/2 cup…it must have been right. Batter looked softer than I was expecting. since i just made a litte more batter. We had to mix it up a little…my muffins look amazing! I see a taster is needed…Sammie ~ the true test, kids never lie well…hum shes back for more! Doent love the nuts, but dad will! Wow super buttery moist and a little golden crispness. Loafs look very moist too. I love that you included the temp to read makes it easy not to second guess if its done yet!
Great recipe…. Thanks for sharing
Shari
You’re very welcome. Glad it made a big impression on your family. I made this a couple of months ago and was wowed myself – it’s so moist and delicious. . . carolyn t
Elsa
said on July 27th, 2015:
I am making this recipe again tonight, this is by far the best banana nut bread recipe. I have tried several banana nut bread recipes, and this one for sure is the BEST, I love it, I shared some with my friends and they totally loved it as well. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing this delicious recipe, I will search no further for any more banana nut bread recipes, this is a keeper……
So glad you liked it as much as I did. I can’t take credit for it – a friend sent it to me, and she found it online, I believe. My mouth is watering as I type – guess it’s time to make this again! . . . carolyn t
Linda
said on February 7th, 2016:
I have tried many recipes for banana nut bread, never 100 percent pleased. I tried this recipe, and I love it. Gave our neighbor Robert four large slices to share. He ate every bite in one sitting!! It is delicious and so moist. Thank you for this recipe. It is a keeper!!
I’m so glad you liked it. It IS a keeper of a recipe! . . . carolyn t
Stacy
said on September 6th, 2016:
I’m not sure what I did wrong but the center collapsed and it was undercooked in the middle. I made one large loaf pan and baked it for one hour. The parts that were cooked were absolutely delicious.
Oh no, Stacy. I’m so sorry! Was the center puffed up when you took it out of the oven, or already deflated? Probably the larger pan wasn’t quite cooked through – it could be the temp in your oven, I suppose. Next time use an instant read thermometer (baked things should be about 195-205F in the center). I’ve begun to rely on my instant read thermometer whenever I bake as it’s so much more reliable than the toothpick test. I hope you’ll try it again; it’s such a good banana bread! I haven’t made it in awhile – maybe I need to, although since this recipe came from a prize-winner, I’m not thinking there’s anything wrong with the recipe. The other culprit COULD be your baking powder – I’ve only had it happen once when a can was past its prime and just wouldn’t do its job. Thanks for letting me know. . . carolyn t
Paul Brown
said on December 11th, 2022:
made this tonight, hubby already asking for it again, fabulous and so simple, thank you for the recipe!!!! I am still full.